Scottsdale Is the Valley's Strongest Seller's Market. Which Scottsdale Do the Numbers Mean?

November 12, 2026
Do you want content like this delivered to your inbox?
Warm afternoon light falls on distinctive low-profile Scottsdale homes nestled among palo verde trees and natural desert landscaping below a low ridge.

In October 2026, the median Scottsdale single-family home sold for $1,225,000, up 5.6% from October 2025. In mid-October, the Cromford Market Index for Scottsdale read 144.2, the highest of the 18 Phoenix-area communities the firm tracks, as Scottsdale Progress reported. The metro-wide index sat at 70.1, well into buyer's-market territory.

Inside the city, though, seller strength varied widely by ZIP code. In October, a home in 85254 sold in a median 48 days at 98.4% of its list price. A home in 85262 took a median 154 days. Both are Scottsdale addresses, but they behave like two different markets, and the citywide figures blend them into one.

The median went up because of which homes sold

A median is the midpoint of the homes that happened to close that month. When fewer homes close and a larger share are expensive ones, the midpoint rises even if no individual home gained a dollar. In the Scottsdale Progress article, Cromford Report senior housing analyst Tina Tamboer is cited for exactly this caution: "Changes in the mix of homes sold — particularly in a market with expensive luxury properties — can push the median higher without producing comparable gains for every homeowner."

Scottsdale's October numbers fit that pattern. Closed single-family sales fell 12.9% year over year to 325, and the average sale price climbed 6.9% to $1,618,450. At the ZIP level, the swings get bigger as the samples get smaller:

  • 85262: The October median jumped 29.4% to $1,537,500 on 38 closings. The year-to-date median rose only 4.9%.
  • 85260: The October median rose 23.5% to $1,125,000 on just 15 closings, down from 42 a year earlier.
  • 85258: The October median fell 8.1% to $1,235,000, yet the year-to-date median was up 2.9%.

A 29% one-month jump and an 8% one-month drop within a few miles of each other say more about which houses closed than about what any of those houses is worth. The median tells a buyer very little about negotiating power. For that, look at how much supply each ZIP has and how close to asking homes are selling.

Where buyer leverage sits, ZIP by ZIP

Here are Scottsdale's ZIP codes for October 2026, ranked from tightest to loosest supply, using Phoenix REALTORS® Local Market Update data current as of November 3, 2026.

ZIP Months of supply Median days to sale % of list price received October median
85254 3.0 48 98.4% $995,000
85258 3.1 76 96.8% $1,235,000
85260 3.5 60 97.3% $1,125,000
85255 3.6 81 96.3% $1,820,000
85259 3.8 51 97.1% $1,499,000
85250 4.2 89 96.8% $825,000
85257 4.7 45 97.6% $635,000
85266 5.4 77 96.1% $1,650,000
85251 5.4 73 93.6% $819,250
85262 7.1 154 96.0% $1,537,500

North Scottsdale's 85255 tightened the most over the year. Its inventory fell 19.1% to 267 homes, and months of supply dropped from 4.9 to 3.6.

Three things stand out in the table.

  1. 85254 is the closest thing Scottsdale has to the market its index ranking describes. Pending sales there fell just 7.0% year over year, compared with a 43.5% drop citywide, and homes sold faster than they did a year earlier.
  2. 85251, around Old Town, had the deepest discount from asking price. Sellers there received 93.6% of list in October, down from 95.3% a year earlier, with 110 single-family homes for sale. On a home listed near $875,000, a 93.6% result works out to roughly $56,000 below asking.
  3. 85262 has the most supply in the city. At 7.1 months, it would take more than half a year to sell every listed home at October's pace, and the median home sat on the market for 154 days, up 38.7% from October 2025.

These are single-month readings, and in a ZIP with 22 closings, a few sales can move every column. The three-year view is steadier, and it points the same way.

Three years of price-per-square-foot gains put the gap in the same places

A separate Cromford analysis cited by Scottsdale Progress looked at median price per square foot over three years, a measure less affected by home size than a straight median.

ZIP Three-year change in median price per sq. ft.
85254 +17.5%
85255 +15.8%
85258 +14.7%
85262 +8.3%
85266 +6.6%
85260 +6.4%
85259 +6.3%
85250 +5.9%
85257 +2.5%
85251 +1.7%

The two ZIPs with the tightest October supply, 85254 and 85258, are also two of the three strongest three-year performers. 85251 is last on both measures: the smallest three-year gain and the deepest October discount from list. Over three years, a buyer in 85254 paid for momentum, and a buyer in 85251 paid for a market that has barely moved per square foot.

Tamboer added two cautions, which Scottsdale Progress reported. ZIP code boundaries don't line up exactly with Scottsdale's city limits, and price-per-square-foot changes can still reflect the mix of homes sold. Even with those limits, the order is consistent enough to guide where a buyer can expect to negotiate.

Every ZIP got the same Valley-wide drop in contracts

One October number does look alarming. Scottsdale's single-family pending sales fell 43.5% year over year, from 368 to 208. That drop was not specific to Scottsdale. On the same Phoenix REALTORS® reports for October:

  • Maricopa County single-family pendings fell 46.2%
  • Chandler fell 54.5%
  • Gilbert fell 50.2%
  • Mesa fell 48.4%
  • Phoenix fell 48.2%

The Cromford-based count of listings under contract across Metro Phoenix, which measures something different, fell 13.5% to 6,347 in October, according to AZ Big Media. Both measures point to softer demand. The pending-sales drop is a Valley-wide trend, so it doesn't help a buyer choose one Scottsdale ZIP over another.

What does separate the ZIPs is how much supply each one has to absorb that softer demand. At an October 20 briefing, Tamboer estimated Valley buyer demand at about 25% below normal and said growing supply had done more to weaken the market index than falling demand had, Scottsdale Progress reported. In 85254, where inventory dipped to 178, softer demand barely registers. In 85262, with 289 homes for sale, it shows up in the time each home sits.

Condos fit the same pattern. Scottsdale's townhouse and condo inventory rose 12.0% year over year to 1,127 in October, and months of supply climbed to 6.6, while single-family inventory held almost flat at 1,480.

The list-price figures leave out concessions

Every price figure on these Phoenix REALTORS® reports carries a footnote saying it "does not account for sale concessions and/or downpayment assistance." So a 96.8% sale-to-list figure can overstate what a seller actually netted.

Phoenix REALTORS® board president Sammy Glassman told Scottsdale Progress that "affordability today is often more about the monthly payment than the purchase price alone," and that buyers may use seller concessions "to buy down their rate or reduce upfront costs." Tamboer's Valley-wide data put the median concession at about $11,000 for homes priced between $350,000 and $400,000, the band where concessions run highest. Freddie Mac's survey had the 30-year fixed rate at 7.18% as of November 5, 2026, so a rate buydown is worth a lot to a buyer.

In practice, how much a Scottsdale seller will offer in concessions depends on the supply numbers in the table. A seller in a 7.1-month ZIP has more reason to fund a buydown than a seller in a 3.0-month ZIP. This is general market information, not financial advice, so talk with your lender about how a concession or rate buydown would affect your own loan. Our guide to 2-1 vs. permanent buydowns in Arizona explains how the two structures work.

Quick answers

Is Scottsdale still a seller's market? Citywide, yes. Scottsdale's Cromford index of 144.2 on October 15 was above the balanced level of 100, although it was down 9% from a month earlier. At the ZIP level, October supply ranged from 3.0 months in 85254 to 7.1 months in 85262.

Did Scottsdale home values rise 5.6% this year? That figure is the change in the October median compared with October 2025. The year-to-date median through October was up 5.9% to $1,250,000. Neither number measures what a specific home gained, because both depend on the mix of homes that sold.

Which October figure is most useful for a buyer? Months of supply and the percent of list price received. They show how much room there is to negotiate, and in October they varied widely across Scottsdale's ZIP codes. For more on how high-end pricing works here, see how luxury pricing really works in Scottsdale.

If you're weighing a home in 85254 against one in 85262 or 85251, the right offer for each one is very different. Celina Acosta Real Estate Group can pull current supply, sale-to-list and concession numbers for the specific ZIP and price range you're considering, in English or Spanish, before you write an offer. Schedule a consultation to see where you can negotiate in Scottsdale this season, or get a free home valuation if you're thinking about selling.

Find Your Dream Home

Browse active listings in the area or contact us for off-market listings.

Home Search

What's Your Home Worth?

Have an expert help you find out what your home is really worth.

Home Valuation